This Site is inactive and The Blue Harbor Hotel is no longer a rental option on Put-in-Bay. Thank you for your interest.
However, if you need help to find a cottage, home, or condo to enjoy while you visit the Island of Put in Bay, we DO have information to help you! We have different cottage options depending on what your put in bay lodging needs are:
- Island Club Cottages - The Island Club features 73 three and four bedroom homes right in the heart of PutinBay. All of our Put-in-Bay vacation homes are fully furnished with central air, full kitchens, two baths, private decks grills and more. If you're visiting Put-in-Bay with friends or family, Put in Bay's Island Club is the place for you.
- Put-in-Bay Condos - 2-Bedroom/2-Bath Condos on the Lake, Private In-Ground Pool, Rock-Skipping Beach, Restaurant & Lounge nearby, Only Eight Units -- Very Private. Completely remodeled in 2012.
- A Place at the Bay Cottage - A Place at the Bay is located across from the Island Club on 1.5 acres just off Put-in-Bay Road. The house is a 4 bedroom 2 bath Island home with a Jacuzzi master suite. A Place at the Bay has room for up to 12 people. Come and enjoy the beautiful island of Put-in-Bay in the wooded privacy of your own private home.
- Peace & Quiet Cottage - Peace and Quiet is the perfect place for those who want to enjoy the nearby hustle and bustle of downtown Put in Bay but would like a relaxing place to go when they need a break. Located less than a mile from Delaware Avenue - the downtown of Put in Bay, Ohio - Peace and Quiet is actually two side-by-side efficiencies that each sleep up to six people. The efficiencies can be rented separately or together.
- Island Club #97 - Ideal for a quick Put-in-Bay getaway or great for a longer term family vacation. House 97 is one of the best Island Club homes for rent. This cedar sided 3 bedroom/2 bathroom house is furnished with everything your bachelorette, fishermen, family, or group needs for a vacation including a fully equipped kitchen, large decks, bbq grill, local cable TV, a DVD/CD player, pillows and comforters, and so much more.